Meta found liable as court blocks firing of moderators
· 2023-06-03

A Kenyan court has ruled that Meta is the primary employer of content moderators suing the social media giant and its content review partner in Africa, Sama, for unlawful dismissal.

25c1acf9508ad3b72f1dbd14663f5d3b.png


A Kenyan court has ruled that Meta is the primary employer of content moderators suing the social media giant and its content review partner in Africa, Sama, for unlawful dismissal. The 184 moderators, in the suit filed in March this year, also alleged that Meta’s new content review partner on the continent, Majorel, had blacklisted them on instruction by Meta.


Justice Byram Ongaya of Kenya’s employment and labor relations court on Friday watered down the social media giant’s plan to recuse itself from the case saying the moderators did Meta’s work, used its technology for the work, as well as adhered to its performance and accuracy metrics. The court said that Sama was “merely an agent…or manager.” Sama disputed this, saying “Meta is a client of Sama’s and Sama is not legally empowered to act on behalf of Meta.”


Meta has not replied to a request for comment.


The latest development is a blow to Meta, which has sought to distance itself from the petition saying that it is not the moderators’ employer.


“The evidence is that the obligation to provide the digital work of content moderation belong to the first and second respondents who provided the digital or virtual workspace for the applicants. The first and second respondents exercise control by imposing the operational requirements and standards of performance. The first and second respondent then provided the remuneration back through the agent [Sama],” the court said.


“The third respondent [Sama] was acting as an agent of the owner of the work of content moderation the first and second respondents [Meta Platforms Inc and Meta Platforms Ireland Limited], there is nothing in the arrangements to absolve the first and second respondents as the primary and principal employers of the content moderators.”


Additionally, the court directed that moderators’ contracts be extended and also barred Meta and Sama from laying them off, pending the determination of the case. The court issued the directions saying there was no suitable justification for the redundancies, and that it had “found that the job of content moderation is available. The applicants will continue working upon the prevailing or better terms in the interim.”


Moderators, hired from across the continent, including from Ethiopia, Uganda, Somalia and South Africa, sift through social media posts on Meta’s platforms to remove content that perpetrates and perpetuates hate, misinformation and violence.


The moderators allege that Sama fired them illegally after failing to issue them with redundancy notices as required by Kenyan law. The suit also claims, among other issues, that the moderators were not issued with a 30-day termination notice, and that their terminal dues were pegged on their signing of non-disclosure documents.


Sama, in the past, told TechCrunch it observed the Kenyan law, and communicated the decision to discontinue content moderation in a town hall, and through email and notification letters.


Sama, whose clients include OpenAI, dropped Meta’s contract and content review services and issued redundancy notices to 260 moderators to concentrate on labeling work (computer vision data annotation).


Meta and Sama are facing two other suits in Kenya; Daniel Motaung, a South African, sued the company for labor and human trafficking, unfair labor relations, union busting and failure to provide “adequate” mental health and psychosocial support. Motaung alleges he was laid off for organizing a 2019 strike and trying to unionize Sama’s employees.


Ethiopians filed another suit in December last year over claims that the social media giant failed to employ enough safety measures on Facebook, which, in turn, fueled the conflicts that have led to deaths, including the father of one of the petitioners, and 500,000 Ethiopians during the Tigray War.













熱門文章
越南博彩管控逐步放寬,惟本土需求仍顯乏力
東南亞資訊
菲律賓博彩技術賽道迎來新變局,B2B 供應模式加速滲透
東南亞資訊
越南在線博彩業政策收緊 催生市場新機遇
東南亞資訊
英國確認各垂直行業的賭博稅稅率
合規與政策
橫跨全球6個城市,灰度8場派對邀你共看世界盃,重塑高質量社交新場景
灰度頭條
2027 Global Game Connect(GGC)斯里蘭卡招商全面啟動!業務人脈盡在掌握!
灰度頭條
西班牙監管機構警告在線賭博平臺存在身份盜竊行為
合規與政策
菲律賓網絡賭博和加密貨幣仍構成持續的洗錢風險
東南亞資訊
巴西擬將博弈稅率提高至24% 稅收將用於社保與醫療領域
合規與政策
JILI 宣佈與全球板球傳奇 AB de Villiers(ABD)達成重磅戰略合作
體育遊戲
亞洲遊戲市場觀察:15大市場熱門遊戲與用戶趨勢
網路遊戲
斯里蘭卡博弈產業大轉型,官方:劍指南亞拉斯維加斯
合規與政策
印度最高法院受理公益訴訟,要求全國禁封「偽裝」成社交遊戲的賭博平台
合規與政策
哈薩克計劃對線上賭場促銷活動進行處罰
合規與政策
超級PAC籌資4800萬美元:體育博彩勢力加碼
合規與政策
首頁
遊戲
合作
發現
我的